BLOG:
NJ Supreme Court Hears Arguments On Dune Case
On May 13, 2013, the Supreme Court heard argument in the case of Borough of Harvey Cedars v. Karan. That case is on appeal from an Appellate Division decision, which affirmed a jury verdict awarding the property owners $375,000 as constitutional just compensation for the partial taking of their private beach-front property. The municipality appealed... Read More
High Court Declines Hearing on Partial Taking of Cemetery
Last week, the New Jersey Supreme Court denied a petition for certification filed by the Diocese of Camden in behalf of St Mary’s Cemetery in Bellmawr. As reported by the Republic.com, in 2010, the New Jersey Department of Transportation acquired by exercise of eminent domain a six acre parcel owned by the church for its... Read More
Mantoloking (NJ) Contemplates Use of Eminent Domain for Dune Easements
This just in – Mantoloking has decided to use eminent domain to acquire private property for the purported public use of dune replenishment. See articles from CBS News and NJ.com. McKirdy & Riskin’s Tony DellaPelle was interviewed and quoted in the CBS news video about the constitutional issues raised by attempting to require that oceanfront property owners... Read More
Arkansas Fish and Game – Remand Briefs
As you know from our December 2012 blog, the United States Supreme Court found that an Army Corps flooding program, which damaged a hardwood forest managed by the Arkansas Game & Fish Commission, may constitute a taking of private property. Therefore, the Court upheld the property owner’s inverse condemnation claim, reversed the Fifth Court’s decision... Read More
More from the Shore – Proposed Legislation Seeks to Limit Just Compensation
Owners of property along the Jersey shore continue to be battered, this time by their own elected officials. The New Jersey Senate recently introduced S-2618, which provides: “Just compensation for an easement over a portion of beachfront property condemned for the purpose of dune construction or beach replenishment shall include consideration of the increase in value... Read More
Hoboken North End Redevelopment Moving Forward
The Hoboken Planning Board recently completed its investigation of a proposed redevelopment area dubbed the North End Redevelopment Area. A full copy of the Study Report is available on the City’s website. Photo courtesy Google maps. As noted in a recent article by Amanda Palasciano of the Hudson Reporter, the next step in the process... Read More
Mortgagee Not Entitled to Bona Fide Negotiations
On February 5, 2012, the Appellate Division published its decision in a condemnation case captioned Borough of Merchantville v. Malik & Son, LLC. The property was acquired by the municipality in connection with an earlier “in need of redevelopment” designation. In short, the Appellate Court affirmed a trial court’s rejection of a “right to take” challenge... Read More
More on Dune Replenishment – Taking Private Property Without Just Compensation
The Borough of Mantoloking is one of several beachfront municipalities that has asked owners of beach-front property to donate their private property to the municipality. A copy of the most recent form of dedication agreement (identified as an easement) is available on the Borough’s website here. The Borough is attempting to force property owners to... Read More
Rebuilding After Sandy: Government Assistance At Odds With Private Property Rights
The following quote is attributed to President Ronald Reagan: One example of government assistance post-Hurricane Sandy was the removal of an entire house because it was allegedly in the right of way: Ortley Beach home removed Well, photographic and video evidence proved that the house was not in the right-of-way, but the State removed and... Read More
In the Wake of a Superstorm the Debate Continues – Who Should Pay for the Dunes?
The debate continues – Can government force private property owners to donate their private property for strengthening a dune system for the benefit the general public when the next superstorm hits? Not in the U. S. of A. A recent National Public Radio program discussed the topic and interviewed property owners and government officials. Governor... Read More
